exp-013 · step 1 of 5 · begin

Can It Admit the Question Is Broken?

field mission · ~8 min · +50 xp

one guided test in an AI you already use

Give an AI a question that's secretly flawed — a false premise, missing information, or a forced either/or that leaves out a real option. Does it notice?

how to run it

ask the AI one question containing a deliberate flaw — pick ONE type: (1) a false premise (e.g. "Why did the Great Wall of China fail to stop Genghis Khan's invasion?" — it didn't; the premise is wrong), (2) missing information needed to answer, (3) two incompatible instructions in one request, (4) a forced either/or that has an obvious third option, or (5) a category error. Note exactly what you asked and what kind of flaw it contained, then report how it responded.

open inChatGPT Claude Gemini· your Lab progress stays here

before you start

This experiment asks you to run a short test on an AI of your choosing outside this site, then report what happened here. Your responses are stored under an anonymous participant ID, never your name or email.